FT·CON·022View & Philosophy
Prasangika and Svatantrika
ཐལ་འགྱུར་བ་དང་རང་རྒྱུད་པ
Wyliethal 'gyur ba dang rang rgyud paSanskritprāsaṅgika, svātantrikaDatedistinction drawn c. 1100
Prasangika and Svatantrika are the two branches into which Tibetan scholars divide Madhyamaka, according to how emptiness should be argued and what is accepted conventionally.
Also known asTalgyurwa and Ranggyupa · Consequence and Autonomy schools · Svatantrika-Prasangika distinction · Prasangika Madhyamaka
Tibetan scholars sort the Indian Madhyamaka masters into two camps. The distinction goes back to a sixth-century dispute. Bhaviveka criticised the commentator Buddhapalita for refuting opponents only by drawing out the unwanted consequences of their views, and held that a Madhyamaka thinker must also state independent proofs of emptiness. Chandrakirti later defended Buddhapalita. Tibetans named Bhaviveka’s approach Svatantrika, from the word for an autonomous argument, and Chandrakirti’s Prasangika, from the word for a consequence. The labels became current around 1100 with the translator Patsab Nyima Drak.
The schools disagree about how deep the difference goes. Tsongkhapa argued that it concerns the view itself: in his reading, Svatantrikas accept that things exist by their own character at the conventional level, while Prasangikas deny intrinsic existence even conventionally. Sakya, Kagyu and Nyingma authors such as Gorampa and Mipham generally see a difference of method and emphasis and not of final understanding. All Tibetan traditions regard Prasangika as the most exact statement of the middle way.
Connections
8 linked records across the archive.
Sources
References consulted for this record.
- 01Svatantrika–Prasangika distinction — Wikipedia
- 02Georges B. J. Dreyfus and Sara L. McClintock (eds), The Svatantrika-Prasangika Distinction: What Difference Does a Difference Make? (Wisdom, 2003)
- 03Madhyamaka — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy