{"wing":"Schools & Lineages","count":12,"records":[{"id":"nyingma","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/nyingma/","code":"FT·SCH·001","name":"Nyingma","aliases":["Nyingmapa","Ngagyur Nyingma","Old Translation School","Ancient School","Early Translation School"],"tibetan":"རྙིང་མ","wylie":"rnying ma","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"8th-century origins","summary":"Oldest of the Tibetan Buddhist schools, tracing its teachings to Padmasambhava and the eighth-century translations, with Dzogchen as its highest view and practice.","body":["The Nyingma, ‘the Ancients’, is the school that follows the tantras translated into Tibetan during the imperial period, from the eighth century to the collapse of the empire in the ninth. It looks to the Indian master Padmasambhava, the abbot Shantarakshita and the emperor Trisong Detsen as its founders. The name arose only in the eleventh century, to distinguish these older lineages from the ‘new’ (sarma) schools formed around later translations. For centuries the tradition was carried chiefly by family lines of lay tantric priests, the ngakpas, and by small hermitages, with few large monasteries.","The Nyingma arrange Buddhist teaching in nine vehicles (yanas). Three belong to the sutras: those of the hearers, the solitary buddhas and the bodhisattvas. Three are outer tantras: kriya, charya and yoga. Three are inner tantras: Mahayoga, centred on the visualisation of deities, with the Guhyagarbha as root tantra; Anuyoga, working with the channels and energies of the subtle body; and Atiyoga or Dzogchen, the ‘Great Perfection’, which introduces the practitioner directly to the primordially pure and spontaneously present nature of mind. Teachings descend by two routes: the long oral transmission (kama) and revealed treasures (terma), held to have been hidden by Padmasambhava and recovered by later tertons.","Longchenpa in the fourteenth century and Jigme Lingpa in the eighteenth gave Dzogchen its classical formulations, and Mipham in the nineteenth supplied a scholastic curriculum. Six ‘mother’ monasteries developed from the twelfth century onward: Kathok, Dorje Drak, Mindrolling, Palyul, Dzogchen and Shechen, most of them re-established in India and Nepal after 1959. The school has no hereditary or elected head; a representative role created in exile was first held by Dudjom Rinpoche. Nyingma practice is widespread across Tibet, Bhutan, Sikkim and Nepal, and at large encampments such as Larung Gar."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"8th century (imperial period); name in use from the 11th century"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Padmasambhava, with Shantarakshita and Trisong Detsen"},{"label":"Head","value":"No single head; a representative role has existed in exile"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Kathok; Dorje Drak; Mindrolling; Palyul; Dzogchen; Shechen"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Nine vehicles; Dzogchen; kama and terma transmissions"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Guhyagarbha Tantra; Nyingma Gyubum; Seven Treasuries; Longchen Nyingthig"},{"label":"Hat colour","value":"Red"},{"label":"Region","value":"All Tibetan regions; Bhutan; Sikkim; Nepal"}],"related":["masters/padmasambhava","concepts/dzogchen","masters/longchenpa","masters/jigme-lingpa","concepts/terma","places/mindrolling","texts/guhyagarbha-tantra","masters/mipham-rinpoche","deities/samantabhadra","deities/vajrakilaya","deities/simhamukha","deities/ekajati","deities/rahula","deities/dorje-legpa","deities/peaceful-and-wrathful-deities","symbols/phurba","masters/trisong-detsen","masters/garab-dorje","masters/terdak-lingpa","masters/patrul-rinpoche","masters/vairotsana","masters/karma-lingpa","masters/jamyang-khyentse-wangpo","masters/sixth-dalai-lama","masters/sera-khandro","masters/yeshe-tsogyal","masters/mandarava","masters/dudjom-rinpoche","masters/dilgo-khyentse","masters/chogyam-trungpa","schools/bon","places/rebkong","places/samye","places/rongbuk","places/dzogchen-monastery","places/kathok","places/larung-gar","places/paro-taktsang","places/bylakuppe","history/trisong-detsen-invites-indian-masters","history/first-seven-monks","history/revolts-and-the-opening-of-the-royal-tombs","history/monastic-ordination-survives-in-amdo","history/yeshe-o-and-rinchen-zangpo","history/longchenpa-systematises-dzogchen","history/sixth-dalai-lama-deposed","history/dzungar-invasion-and-qing-expedition","texts/nyingma-gyubum","texts/seven-treasuries","texts/words-of-my-perfect-teacher","texts/life-of-padmasambhava","concepts/rigpa","concepts/trekcho-and-togal","concepts/nine-yanas","concepts/rainbow-body","concepts/terton","concepts/khenpo","concepts/ngakpa"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Nyingma — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nyingma"},{"title":"Nyingma — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Nyingma"},{"title":"Dudjom Rinpoche, The Nyingma School of Tibetan Buddhism: Its Fundamentals and History, trans. Gyurme Dorje and Matthew Kapstein (Wisdom Publications, 1991)","url":""}]},{"id":"kadam","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/kadam/","code":"FT·SCH·002","name":"Kadam","aliases":["Kadampa","Kadam School","Old Kadam","Bka' gdams"],"tibetan":"བཀའ་གདམས","wylie":"bka' gdams","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"founded 1056–57","summary":"School founded by Atisha’s disciple Dromtonpa in the eleventh century, known for monastic discipline, the graded path and mind training; later absorbed into the Gelug.","body":["The Kadam was the first of the new schools of the ‘later spread’ of Buddhism in Tibet. It grew from the teaching of the Bengali master Atisha, who worked in Tibet from 1042 until his death in 1054, and was organised by his lay disciple Dromtonpa, who founded Reting monastery north of Lhasa in 1056 or 1057. The name is usually explained as ‘those who take all the Buddha’s words (ka) as personal instruction (dam)’. Kadam teachers were admired for plain living, strict ethics and reticence about tantra.","Kadam teaching rests on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path to Enlightenment, which arranges practice in stages suited to persons of lesser, middling and greater scope: those seeking a good rebirth, those seeking freedom from cyclic existence, and those seeking buddhahood for the sake of all. This became the lamrim, ‘stages of the path’. Its companion is lojong, ‘mind training’, methods for generating bodhichitta, especially the exchange of self and other, codified in Langri Thangpa’s Eight Verses and Chekawa’s Seven Points. Practitioners relied on four deities, Shakyamuni, Avalokiteshvara, Tara and Achala,. Three lineages descended from Dromtonpa’s chief students: the scriptural, the instructional and the oral-precept traditions.","Other centres followed, among them Sangphu Neuthok, founded in 1073, which became Tibet’s leading college of logic and philosophy, and Narthang, founded in 1153 and known for its early compilation of the canon. Kadam methods entered the Kagyu school through Gampopa and influenced the Sakya. In the fifteenth century Tsongkhapa built his reform on Kadam foundations, and his followers were called the ‘New Kadam’; the older monasteries were absorbed into the Gelug school. No independent Kadam order survives, but its lamrim and lojong are practised in every Tibetan tradition."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"1056/57, with the founding of Reting monastery"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Dromtonpa, on the teachings of Atisha"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Reting"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Lamrim (stages of the path); lojong (mind training)"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Lamp for the Path; Seven Points of Mind Training; Book of Kadam"},{"label":"Sub-schools","value":"Scriptural, instructional and oral-precept lineages"},{"label":"Later history","value":"Absorbed into the Gelug school in the 15th century"},{"label":"Region","value":"Central Tibet"}],"related":["masters/atisha","masters/dromtonpa","schools/gelug","concepts/lamrim","concepts/lojong","masters/tsongkhapa","concepts/bodhichitta","masters/gampopa","deities/white-tara","masters/rinchen-zangpo","places/guge-kingdom","places/reting","places/tholing","places/drak-yerpa","places/narthang","history/monastic-ordination-survives-in-amdo","history/atisha-arrives-in-tibet","history/reting-founded","history/gampopa-founds-daklha-gampo","history/mongol-raid-of-1240","history/old-narthang-kangyur-compiled","texts/jewel-ornament-of-liberation","texts/lamrim-chenmo","texts/blue-annals","concepts/tonglen"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Kadam (Tibetan Buddhism) — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kadam_(Tibetan_Buddhism)"},{"title":"Kadampa — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Kadampa"},{"title":"Reting Monastery — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reting_Monastery"},{"title":"Thupten Jinpa (trans.), The Book of Kadam: The Core Texts (Wisdom Publications, 2008)","url":""}]},{"id":"kagyu","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/kagyu/","code":"FT·SCH·003","name":"Kagyu","aliases":["Kagyupa","Kagyud","Dakpo Kagyu","Marpa Kagyu","Oral Lineage"],"tibetan":"བཀའ་བརྒྱུད","wylie":"bka' brgyud","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"11th–12th century","summary":"Family of lineages descending from Marpa, Milarepa and Gampopa, centred on Mahamudra meditation and the Six Dharmas of Naropa and known for its hermit yogins.","body":["The Kagyu, ‘lineage of the oral instructions’, is one of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. It traces its teachings from the buddha Vajradhara through the Indian adepts Tilopa and Naropa to the Tibetan translator Marpa in the eleventh century, then to the hermit-poet Milarepa and his student Gampopa. Gampopa, a monk trained in the Kadam school, combined monastic life with the yogic practices he had received and founded Daklha Gampo in 1121. The many branches that derive from him are known collectively as the Dakpo Kagyu.","Two bodies of practice define the school. Mahamudra, the ‘Great Seal’, is a set of instructions for recognising the nature of mind as empty, luminous and unimpeded. It is taught through calm abiding and insight meditation, through tantric practice, or by direct introduction from the teacher, and its progress is described in four stages, the four yogas. The Six Dharmas of Naropa are tantric yogas of the completion stage: inner heat, illusory body, dream, clear light, the intermediate state and transference of consciousness. Both rest on devotion to the teacher. The principal deities are Chakrasamvara and Vajravarahi, and the three-year retreat is the standard training of a Kagyu lama.","Tradition counts ‘four senior and eight junior’ branches. The senior lines, founded by Gampopa’s direct heirs, are the Karma, Barom, Tsalpa and Phagdru Kagyu; the junior, founded by students of Phagmo Drupa, include the Drikung, Taklung and Drukpa. The Karma, Drikung, Drukpa and Taklung survive as independent orders with their own heads, the Drukpa being the state tradition of Bhutan. The Shangpa Kagyu is a separate lineage with a similar name. Kagyu hierarchs held political power in Tibet between the fourteenth and seventeenth centuries, and the school is now established worldwide."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"11th–12th century; Daklha Gampo founded 1121"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Marpa, Milarepa and Gampopa"},{"label":"Head","value":"No single head; each branch has its own hierarch"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Daklha Gampo (Dakpo Kagyu)"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Mahamudra; Six Dharmas of Naropa"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Jewel Ornament of Liberation; songs of Milarepa; Mahamudra manuals"},{"label":"Sub-schools","value":"Karma, Drikung, Drukpa, Taklung and others"},{"label":"Indian sources","value":"Tilopa; Naropa; Maitripa"}],"related":["masters/marpa","masters/milarepa","masters/gampopa","concepts/mahamudra","concepts/six-yogas-of-naropa","schools/karma-kagyu","schools/drukpa-kagyu","schools/shangpa-kagyu","deities/vajradhara","deities/chakrasamvara","deities/four-armed-mahakala","deities/achi-chokyi-drolma","deities/tseringma","symbols/karma-gadri-style","masters/tilopa","masters/naropa","masters/dusum-khyenpa","masters/phagmo-drupa","masters/tsangnyon-heruka","masters/zhabdrung-ngawang-namgyal","masters/sixteenth-karmapa","masters/chogyam-trungpa","places/punakha-dzong","places/tsurphu","places/drigung-til","places/hemis","places/tsari","places/paro-taktsang","places/rumtek","history/marpa-brings-naropa-lineage","history/milarepa-the-poet-yogin","history/gampopa-founds-daklha-gampo","history/zhabdrung-unifies-bhutan","texts/chakrasamvara-tantra","texts/jewel-ornament-of-liberation","texts/songs-of-milarepa","texts/life-of-milarepa","texts/blue-annals","concepts/retreat","concepts/tummo","concepts/phowa","concepts/khenpo"],"artworks":["cma-153618"],"sources":[{"title":"Kagyu — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kagyu"},{"title":"Mahamudra — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahamudra"},{"title":"Peter Alan Roberts (trans.), Mahāmudrā and Related Instructions: Core Teachings of the Kagyü Schools (Wisdom Publications, 2011)","url":""}]},{"id":"sakya","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/sakya/","code":"FT·SCH·004","name":"Sakya","aliases":["Sakyapa","Sakya School","Sa skya","Pale Earth School"],"tibetan":"ས་སྐྱ","wylie":"sa skya","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"founded 1073","summary":"School founded at Sakya monastery in 1073 by the Khon family, noted for its scholarship and for the Lamdre, the ‘Path with its Result’, centred on the Hevajra Tantra.","body":["The Sakya school takes its name from the monastery founded in 1073 by Khon Konchok Gyalpo at a site of ‘pale earth’ (sa kya) in Tsang. Leadership has remained in the Khon family ever since. Five early masters, called the five founding patriarchs, shaped the tradition: Sachen Kunga Nyingpo, his sons Sonam Tsemo and Drakpa Gyaltsen, Sakya Pandita and Chogyal Phagpa. Through the last two the school became the agent of Mongol authority, and Sakya administrators governed Tibet from the 1260s until 1354.","The central teaching is the Lamdre, ‘the Path with its Result’, which originates with the Indian adept Virupa and is based on the Hevajra Tantra. It presents the whole path, from the sutra teachings on renunciation and compassion, set out as the ‘three visions’, to the tantric practice of the ‘three continua’. Its characteristic view is the inseparability of samsara and nirvana: the mind’s nature is the union of clarity and emptiness, so the result is already present in the path. Other hallmarks are Parting from the Four Attachments, the Vajrayogini practice of Naropa’s tradition, the protector Mahakala Panjaranatha, and a rigorous curriculum in logic founded by Sakya Pandita.","Two main sub-schools arose: the Ngor, founded by Ngorchen Kunga Zangpo in 1429, and the Tsar, deriving from Tsarchen Losal Gyatso in the sixteenth century. Scholars such as Gorampa and Shakya Chokden defined Sakya philosophy. The head of the school is the Sakya Trizin, ‘holder of the Sakya throne’. The forty-first, born in 1945, led the school in exile from Rajpur in India for more than fifty years; since 2017 the office has passed in fixed terms among qualified members of the family’s two palaces. Sakya buildings are recognisable by their grey walls with red and white stripes."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"1073"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Khon Konchok Gyalpo"},{"label":"Head","value":"Sakya Trizin, from the Khon family"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Sakya, Tsang"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Lamdre (Path with its Result); Hevajra"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Vajra Verses of Virupa; Hevajra Tantra; Parting from the Four Attachments"},{"label":"Sub-schools","value":"Ngor; Tsar"},{"label":"Region","value":"Tsang; Derge in Kham; seat in exile at Rajpur, India"}],"related":["masters/khon-konchok-gyalpo","masters/sachen-kunga-nyingpo","masters/sakya-pandita","masters/chogyal-phagpa","masters/virupa","deities/hevajra","places/sakya-monastery","deities/vajrayogini","deities/yamantaka","deities/vajrakilaya","deities/kurukulla","deities/panjaranatha-mahakala","deities/begtse","deities/ganapati","symbols/khyenri-style","symbols/newar-beri-style","masters/phagmo-drupa","masters/jamyang-khyentse-wangpo","masters/buton-rinchen-drub","places/lo-manthang","places/drigung-til","places/shalu","history/sakya-founded","history/mongol-raid-of-1240","history/sakya-pandita-meets-godan-khan","history/phagpa-and-kublai-khan","history/phagpa-script-created","history/changchub-gyaltsen-ends-sakya-rule","history/derge-parkhang-founded","texts/hevajra-tantra","concepts/khenpo"],"artworks":["met-37831","met-73300","mia-12995","mia-12996"],"sources":[{"title":"Sakya — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya"},{"title":"Lamdre — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamdre"},{"title":"Sakya — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Sakya"},{"title":"Sakya Trizin — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya_Trizin"}]},{"id":"gelug","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/gelug/","code":"FT·SCH·005","name":"Gelug","aliases":["Gelugpa","Geluk","Gandenpa","New Kadam","Yellow Hat School"],"tibetan":"དགེ་ལུགས","wylie":"dge lugs","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"founded 1409","summary":"Largest school of Tibetan Buddhism, founded by Tsongkhapa in the early fifteenth century, emphasising monastic discipline, philosophical study and the graded path.","body":["The Gelug, ‘the virtuous tradition’, arose from the teaching of Tsongkhapa (1357–1419). Its founding is dated to 1409, when he established Ganden monastery east of Lhasa; the school was first called Gandenpa, and also ‘New Kadam’, since Tsongkhapa saw his work as a renewal of Atisha’s tradition. His students founded Drepung in 1416 and Sera in 1419, the other two of the ‘three seats’ near Lhasa, and Tashilhunpo at Shigatse in 1447. With Mongol support the school came to political power in 1642 under the Fifth Dalai Lama and governed Tibet until 1959.","Gelug training joins three elements. The first is strict observance of the monastic code. The second is prolonged study of five subjects through memorisation and formal debate: logic and epistemology, the Perfection of Wisdom, Madhyamaka, Abhidharma and monastic discipline, leading after some twenty years to the degree of geshe. In philosophy the school follows the Prasangika Madhyamaka of Chandrakirti as explained by Tsongkhapa, for whom emptiness means the absence of intrinsic existence and leaves conventional cause and effect intact. The third is the lamrim, the graded path set out in Tsongkhapa’s Great Treatise. Tantra is entered only on this basis, chiefly through the Guhyasamaja, Chakrasamvara, Yamantaka and Kalachakra systems.","The head of the school is the Ganden Tripa, ‘holder of the Ganden throne’, an office filled by seniority and scholarship for a seven-year term; it is not held by the Dalai Lama, who is the school’s most prominent teacher. The Dalai Lamas and Panchen Lamas are its best-known incarnation lines. The Gelug became dominant in central Tibet, Amdo and Mongolia, and among the Kalmyks and Buryats of Russia. After 1959 the three seats and the Gyuto and Gyume tantric colleges were re-established in India, the three seats in Karnataka, where they house several thousand monks."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"1409, with the founding of Ganden monastery"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Tsongkhapa Lobsang Drakpa"},{"label":"Head","value":"Ganden Tripa, appointed for a seven-year term"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Ganden; with Drepung and Sera, the 'three seats'"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Lamrim; Prasangika Madhyamaka; monastic scholasticism"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Lamrim Chenmo; Ngakrim Chenmo; the five great Indian treatises"},{"label":"Hat colour","value":"Yellow"},{"label":"Region","value":"Central Tibet; Amdo; Mongolia; re-established in India"}],"related":["masters/tsongkhapa","places/ganden","places/drepung","places/sera","texts/lamrim-chenmo","science/monastic-debate","masters/fourteenth-dalai-lama","schools/kadam","deities/guhyasamaja","deities/yamantaka","deities/six-armed-mahakala","deities/yama-dharmaraja","deities/begtse","deities/white-mahakala","symbols/butter-sculpture","science/pramana","science/collected-topics","masters/dromtonpa","masters/khedrub-je","masters/zanabazar","masters/first-dalai-lama","masters/second-dalai-lama","masters/third-dalai-lama","masters/fifth-dalai-lama","masters/sixth-dalai-lama","masters/seventh-dalai-lama","masters/thirteenth-dalai-lama","masters/first-panchen-lama-lobsang-chokyi-gyaltsen","masters/tenth-panchen-lama","places/rebkong","places/ramoche","places/reting","places/tashilhunpo","places/litang-monastery","places/kumbum-monastery","places/labrang","places/tawang","places/erdene-zuu","places/yonghe-temple","places/tsaparang","places/bylakuppe","history/reting-founded","history/ganden-and-the-great-prayer-festival","history/drepung-and-sera-founded","history/rinpungpa-and-tsangpa-rule","history/tashilhunpo-founded","history/dalai-lama-title-conferred","history/fourth-dalai-lama-born-in-mongolia","history/ganden-phodrang-established","history/fifth-dalai-lama-visits-beijing","history/dzungar-invasion-and-qing-expedition","texts/guhyasamaja-tantra","texts/pramanavarttika","concepts/prasangika-and-svatantrika","concepts/geshe","concepts/monlam-chenmo","concepts/ganden-ngamcho"],"artworks":["cma-150468","cma-119786"],"sources":[{"title":"Gelug — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gelug"},{"title":"Gelug — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Gelug"},{"title":"Ganden Tripa — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ganden_Tripa"},{"title":"Georges B. J. Dreyfus, The Sound of Two Hands Clapping: The Education of a Tibetan Buddhist Monk (University of California Press, 2003)","url":""}]},{"id":"jonang","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/jonang/","code":"FT·SCH·006","name":"Jonang","aliases":["Jonangpa","Jonang School","Jo nang"],"tibetan":"ཇོ་ནང","wylie":"jo nang","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"founded 1294","summary":"School centred on the Kalachakra Tantra and the zhentong view of buddha-nature, suppressed in central Tibet in the seventeenth century and still active in Amdo.","body":["The Jonang takes its name from a valley in Tsang where the master Kunpang Thukje Tsondru founded a hermitage in 1294. Its distinctive teachings are traced further back, to the eleventh-century Kalachakra adept Yumo Mikyo Dorje. The school came to prominence under Dolpopa Sherab Gyaltsen (1292–1361), who systematised its philosophy and built the great stupa of Jonang, and flourished again under Taranatha (1575–1634), who founded the monastery of Takten Damcho Ling with the support of the rulers of Tsang.","Jonang doctrine is known as zhentong, ‘emptiness of other’, or the Great Madhyamaka. It holds that all conditioned things are empty of any nature of their own, but that the ultimate reality, buddha-nature, is empty only of what is other than itself, namely adventitious defilements. That ultimate is described positively as permanent, luminous awareness endowed with the qualities of awakening. The teaching draws on the buddha-nature sutras, the treatises of Maitreya and above all the Kalachakra Tantra. Jonang practice centres on the Kalachakra’s six-branch vajra yoga, a completion-stage system that includes retreat in darkness to cultivate visionary ‘empty forms’, and the school preserves the most complete transmission of it.","After the Fifth Dalai Lama’s government took power, the Jonang monasteries of central Tibet were converted to the Gelug school around 1650 and the printing of Jonang texts was restricted; political ties with the defeated rulers of Tsang as well as doctrinal objections were factors. The tradition continued in Amdo, around Dzamthang, Ngawa and Golok, where several dozen monasteries are active today. Its texts were republished from the late twentieth century, a monastery was established in Shimla, India, and Jonang representatives have sought recognition alongside the other schools in the exile administration."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"1294, as a hermitage at Jonang in Tsang"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Kunpang Thukje Tsondru; systematised by Dolpopa"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Jonang; later Takten Damcho Ling; today Dzamthang Tsangwa"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Zhentong; Kalachakra six-branch yoga"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Mountain Dharma; Kalachakra Tantra; works of Taranatha"},{"label":"Region","value":"Amdo: Dzamthang, Ngawa and Golok"},{"label":"Later history","value":"Central Tibetan monasteries converted to Gelug c. 1650"},{"label":"Forerunner","value":"Yumo Mikyo Dorje (11th century)"}],"related":["masters/dolpopa","masters/taranatha","deities/kalachakra","texts/kalachakra-tantra","concepts/buddha-nature","concepts/emptiness","masters/fifth-dalai-lama","masters/zanabazar","symbols/tenfold-powerful-one","science/kalachakra-cosmology","places/dzamthang","history/kalachakra-and-first-rabjung-cycle","history/dolpopa-and-the-great-stupa-of-jonang","history/rinpungpa-and-tsangpa-rule","concepts/rangtong-and-zhentong","concepts/kalachakra-initiation"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Jonang — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonang"},{"title":"Jonang — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Jonang"},{"title":"Cyrus Stearns, The Buddha from Dolpo: A Study of the Life and Thought of the Tibetan Master Dolpopa Sherab Gyaltsen (Snow Lion, 2010)","url":""},{"title":"Michael R. Sheehy and Klaus-Dieter Mathes (eds), The Other Emptiness: Rethinking the Zhentong Buddhist Discourse in Tibet (SUNY Press, 2019)","url":""}]},{"id":"bon","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/bon/","code":"FT·SCH·007","name":"Bon","aliases":["Bön","Yungdrung Bon","Bonpo","Eternal Bon","Bön religion"],"tibetan":"བོན","wylie":"bon","sanskrit":"","category":"Major School","era":"organised form from the 10th–11th century","summary":"Tibet’s own religious tradition, tracing its teachings to Tonpa Shenrab, with its own canon, monasteries, nine ways of practice and Dzogchen lineages.","body":["Bön is the religious tradition that Tibetans regard as native to their land and as older than Buddhism. Its followers, the Bönpo, hold that it was taught by the buddha Tonpa Shenrab in the land of Olmo Lungring, spread to the kingdom of Zhangzhung in what is now western Tibet, and reached central Tibet before the Buddhist kings, under whom it was twice suppressed. The form practised today is called Yungdrung Bön, ‘eternal Bön’. Historians distinguish the priests called bon and shen who served the imperial court, the organised religion documented from the tenth and eleventh centuries, and later developments known as New Bön.","Bön presents a complete path to buddhahood. Its teachings are arranged as nine ways: four ‘causal’ ways concerned with divination, astrology, healing and funerary ritual, and five ‘resultant’ ways covering lay and monastic ethics, tantra and, as the summit, Dzogchen, the Great Perfection. Three Dzogchen systems are transmitted: the Oral Transmission of Zhangzhung, held to descend unbroken from Zhangzhung masters; the A-tri, ‘guidance of the letter A’; and a third known simply as Dzogchen. The canon comprises a Kangyur of the founder’s words, in about 180 volumes, and a Katen of commentaries, in about 300. Bönpos circumambulate counter-clockwise and recite mantras such as om matri muye sale du.","The treasure revealer Shenchen Luga recovered key scriptures in 1017, and Nyammed Sherab Gyaltsen founded Menri in 1405 as the mother monastery, later joined by Yungdrung Ling. Bön remained strong in Kham, Amdo, Gyalrong and parts of Nepal such as Dolpo. Over a millennium Bön and Buddhism shaped one another deeply. In exile, Menri was re-established at Dolanji in Himachal Pradesh, and Bön is represented in the Tibetan parliament in exile alongside the four Buddhist schools. Its head is the Menri Trizin, the abbot of Menri."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"Traditionally by Tonpa Shenrab; organised form from the 10th–11th century"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Tonpa Shenrab Miwo (traditional)"},{"label":"Head","value":"Menri Trizin, abbot of Menri"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Menri (1405); Yungdrung Ling (1834)"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Nine ways of Bön; Dzogchen"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Bön Kangyur and Katen; Zhangzhung Nyengyu; Dzo Phuk"},{"label":"Sub-schools","value":"Yungdrung Bön; New Bön"},{"label":"Region","value":"Kham; Amdo; Gyalrong; Dolpo; Dolanji in India"}],"related":["masters/tonpa-shenrab","masters/shenchen-luga","masters/nyammed-sherab-gyaltsen","concepts/dzogchen","places/mount-kailash","concepts/terma","schools/nyingma","schools/chod-tradition","deities/samantabhadra","deities/shenlha-okar","deities/garuda","deities/sipai-gyalmo","deities/naga","deities/machen-pomra","symbols/torma","symbols/incense-and-sang","symbols/yungdrung","symbols/cairns-and-lhatse","masters/nyatri-tsenpo","places/menri-monastery","places/amnye-machen","places/khyunglung","history/rise-of-zhangzhung","texts/epic-of-gesar","concepts/rigpa","concepts/dream-yoga","concepts/rainbow-body","concepts/ngakpa"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Bon — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bon"},{"title":"Per Kvaerne, The Bon Religion of Tibet: The Iconography of a Living Tradition (Serindia, 1995)","url":""},{"title":"David L. Snellgrove, The Nine Ways of Bon: Excerpts from gZi-brjid (Oxford University Press, 1967)","url":""},{"title":"Samten G. Karmay, The Arrow and the Spindle: Studies in History, Myths, Rituals and Beliefs in Tibet (Mandala Book Point, 1998)","url":""}]},{"id":"karma-kagyu","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/karma-kagyu/","code":"FT·SCH·008","name":"Karma Kagyu","aliases":["Karma Kamtsang","Kamtsang Kagyu","Karma Kagyud","Karmapa School"],"tibetan":"ཀརྨ་བཀའ་བརྒྱུད","wylie":"karma bka' brgyud","sanskrit":"","category":"Sub-school & Lineage","era":"12th century","summary":"Largest branch of the Kagyu school, founded by the first Karmapa Dusum Khyenpa in the twelfth century and led by the Karmapas, the oldest tulku lineage.","body":["The Karma Kagyu, also called Karma Kamtsang, is the most widespread of the Kagyu orders. It was founded by Dusum Khyenpa (1110–1193), a student of Gampopa, who established Karma Gon in Kham, from which the school is named, and in 1189 Tsurphu in the Tolung valley near Lhasa, its principal seat. After his death his successors were identified as his rebirths, so that the Karmapas form the earliest line of recognised reincarnate lamas in Tibet. The Karmapa is called the ‘Black Hat’ lama after the crown that symbolises his office.","The school teaches the Mahamudra and Six Dharmas of Naropa common to the Kagyu, in a form shaped by its own masters. The third Karmapa, Rangjung Dorje, joined Mahamudra with the Dzogchen of the Nyingma and wrote basic texts on buddha-nature and the subtle body; the eighth, Mikyo Dorje, composed major philosophical commentaries and liturgies; the ninth, Wangchuk Dorje, wrote three Mahamudra manuals, of which the Ocean of Definitive Meaning is the fullest. Chakrasamvara, Vajravarahi and Gyalwa Gyatso are principal meditation deities, and the black-cloaked Mahakala is the protector. Many of its teachers favour the zhentong view. Training culminates in the three-year retreat designed by Jamgon Kongtrul.","Other incarnation lines share in transmitting the lineage, notably the Shamar, Tai Situ, Gyaltsab and Jamgon Kongtrul tulkus; Palpung in Derge, seat of the Tai Situ, was the school’s main centre in eastern Tibet. The Karmapas were influential at the Mongol and Ming courts and in Tibetan politics until 1642. The sixteenth Karmapa built a seat in exile at Rumtek in Sikkim. Since the 1990s two claimants, Ogyen Trinley Dorje and Trinley Thaye Dorje, have each been recognised as the seventeenth Karmapa by different parties; the two met in 2018 and have since issued joint statements."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"12th century; Tsurphu founded 1189"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Dusum Khyenpa, the first Karmapa"},{"label":"Head","value":"The Karmapa"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Tsurphu; Rumtek, Sikkim, in exile"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Mahamudra; Six Dharmas of Naropa"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Ocean of Definitive Meaning; Profound Inner Principle"},{"label":"Other lineage holders","value":"Shamar; Tai Situ; Gyaltsab; Jamgon Kongtrul"},{"label":"Hat colour","value":"Black crown of the Karmapa"}],"related":["schools/kagyu","masters/dusum-khyenpa","masters/rangjung-dorje","masters/sixteenth-karmapa","places/tsurphu","concepts/mahamudra","masters/situ-panchen","masters/choying-dorje","deities/vajravarahi","deities/four-armed-mahakala","symbols/karma-gadri-style","masters/jamgon-kongtrul","masters/chogyam-trungpa","schools/drukpa-kagyu","places/palpung","places/rumtek","history/tsurphu-founded","history/karma-pakshi-recognised-as-rebirth","history/rinpungpa-and-tsangpa-rule","history/karmapa-escape","texts/treasury-of-knowledge","concepts/reincarnation-recognition","concepts/tulku"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Karma Kagyu — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karma_Kagyu"},{"title":"Karmapa — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karmapa"},{"title":"Karma Thinley, The History of the Sixteen Karmapas of Tibet (Prajna Press, 1980)","url":""}]},{"id":"drukpa-kagyu","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/drukpa-kagyu/","code":"FT·SCH·009","name":"Drukpa Kagyu","aliases":["Drukpa","Drukpa Lineage","Dugpa","Druk School","Dragon Lineage"],"tibetan":"འབྲུག་པ་བཀའ་བརྒྱུད","wylie":"'brug pa bka' brgyud","sanskrit":"","category":"Sub-school & Lineage","era":"founded c. 1200","summary":"Kagyu order founded by Tsangpa Gyare around 1200 and named after the thunder dragon; the state tradition of Bhutan and a major school in Ladakh and the Himalaya.","body":["The Drukpa Kagyu is one of the eight ‘junior’ branches of the Dakpo Kagyu, descending from Gampopa through Phagmo Drupa and his student Lingrepa. Its founder was Lingrepa’s disciple Tsangpa Gyare Yeshe Dorje (1161–1211). After establishing Ralung in Tsang, which became the main seat, he founded a monastery at a place where, according to tradition, nine dragons rose into the sky with a roar of thunder. Dragon is druk in Tibetan, and the monastery, the school and its followers took the name.","The Drukpa share Mahamudra and the Six Dharmas of Naropa with the other Kagyu schools and are known for an emphasis on austere retreat; a Tibetan saying held that half the Drukpas were hermits and half the hermits were saints. Two sets of instructions are particular to them. The Six Cycles of Equal Taste, said to have been hidden by Rechungpa and recovered by Tsangpa Gyare, train the meditator to take illness, emotion, obstacles and death as the path. The Seven Auspicious Teachings on interdependence were received by the founder in a vision of seven buddhas. Pema Karpo (1527–1592), the fourth Gyalwang Drukpa, systematised the school’s doctrine.","Early disciples established the Upper, Lower and Middle Drukpa, and the school spread to Ladakh, Zanskar, Lahaul, Kinnaur and Nepal. A dispute over Pema Karpo’s rebirth divided it. Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal left for the south in 1616 and founded Bhutan, where the Southern Drukpa is the state religion under the Je Khenpo. The Northern Drukpa continued in Tibet under the Gyalwang Drukpa incarnations, who are now based in India and Nepal, with Hemis in Ladakh as a principal monastery. The unconventional saint Drukpa Kunley belongs to this school."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"c. 1200, with Ralung and Druk monasteries"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Tsangpa Gyare Yeshe Dorje (1161–1211)"},{"label":"Head","value":"Gyalwang Drukpa (Northern); Je Khenpo of Bhutan (Southern)"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Ralung, Tsang"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Mahamudra; Six Cycles of Equal Taste; Seven Auspicious Teachings"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Collected works of Pema Karpo"},{"label":"Sub-schools","value":"Upper, Lower and Middle Drukpa; Northern and Southern branches"},{"label":"Region","value":"Bhutan; Ladakh; Himalayan India and Nepal; Tibet"}],"related":["schools/kagyu","masters/zhabdrung-ngawang-namgyal","masters/phagmo-drupa","concepts/mahamudra","concepts/six-yogas-of-naropa","masters/gampopa","masters/milarepa","schools/karma-kagyu"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Drukpa Kagyu — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drukpa_Kagyu"},{"title":"Tsangpa Gyare — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsangpa_Gyare"},{"title":"Karma Phuntsho, The History of Bhutan (Random House India, 2013)","url":""}]},{"id":"shangpa-kagyu","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/shangpa-kagyu/","code":"FT·SCH·010","name":"Shangpa Kagyu","aliases":["Shangpa","Shangpa Kagyud","Shangpa Lineage","Shangs pa bka' brgyud"],"tibetan":"ཤངས་པ་བཀའ་བརྒྱུད","wylie":"shangs pa bka' brgyud","sanskrit":"","category":"Sub-school & Lineage","era":"11th–12th century","summary":"Practice lineage founded by Khyungpo Naljor on the teachings of the dakinis Niguma and Sukhasiddhi, distinct from the Kagyu of Marpa and preserved mainly in retreat.","body":["The Shangpa Kagyu is an independent lineage of meditation instruction that shares the name Kagyu, ‘oral lineage’, with the schools descending from Marpa but has a different origin. It was founded by Khyungpo Naljor, a Tibetan of the eleventh and twelfth centuries who began as a Bön and Nyingma practitioner and travelled repeatedly to Nepal and India. He is said to have studied with one hundred and fifty teachers, chief among them two women regarded as wisdom dakinis, Niguma and Sukhasiddhi. On his return he settled in the Shang valley of Tsang, from which the lineage is named.","The core of the tradition is the Five Golden Dharmas of Niguma, pictured as a tree. The roots are the Six Dharmas of Niguma: inner heat, illusory body, dream, clear light, transference and the intermediate state, a set parallel to the Six Dharmas of Naropa. The trunk is the ‘Amulet Box’ Mahamudra; the branches are three ways of carrying experience into the path; the flowers are the white and red forms of the dakini Khechari; and the fruit is the instruction called ‘deathless and unerring’. With these go the teachings of Sukhasiddhi and the practice of the Six-Armed Mahakala, a protector later adopted throughout the Gelug school.","Niguma required that the teaching pass to one disciple only for seven generations, and it was opened more widely by the seventh holder, Sangye Tonpa, in the thirteenth century. The Shangpa never formed a large monastic order; its instructions were held within other schools by masters such as Thangtong Gyalpo, Taranatha and Jamgon Kongtrul, who included them among the eight great practice lineages. In the twentieth century Kalu Rinpoche (1905–1989) taught them widely in Asia and the West, and three-year retreats in the tradition continue."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"11th–12th century"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Khyungpo Naljor"},{"label":"Head","value":"No single head; held by retreat masters"},{"label":"Mother monastery","value":"Zhangzhong, Shang valley, Tsang"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Five Golden Dharmas; Six Dharmas of Niguma"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Vajra Lines of Niguma; Shangpa texts in the Treasury of Instructions"},{"label":"Indian sources","value":"Niguma; Sukhasiddhi; Rahula; Maitripa; Vajrasanapa"},{"label":"Protector","value":"Six-Armed Mahakala"}],"related":["masters/niguma","masters/thangtong-gyalpo","masters/taranatha","masters/jamgon-kongtrul","schools/kagyu","concepts/mahamudra","deities/mahakala","concepts/dakini","schools/rime-movement"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Shangpa Kagyu — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shangpa_Kagyu"},{"title":"Khyungpo Naljor — Rigpa Shedra Wiki","url":"https://rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Khyungpo_Naljor"},{"title":"Sarah Harding, Niguma, Lady of Illusion (Snow Lion, 2010)","url":""},{"title":"Nicole Riggs (trans.), Like an Illusion: Lives of the Shangpa Kagyu Masters (Dharma Cloud, 2001)","url":""}]},{"id":"rime-movement","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/rime-movement/","code":"FT·SCH·011","name":"Rime Movement","aliases":["Rimé","Rime","Ris-med","Nonsectarian Movement","Eclectic Movement"],"tibetan":"རིས་མེད","wylie":"ris med","sanskrit":"","category":"Movement & Practice Lineage","era":"19th century","summary":"Nineteenth-century movement in Kham, led by Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo and Jamgon Kongtrul, that collected and transmitted the teachings of all lineages without sectarian bias.","body":["Rime, ‘without partiality’, names an approach to the diversity of Tibetan Buddhism and the nineteenth-century movement that embodied it. Its centre was the kingdom of Derge in Kham, whose rulers patronised monasteries of several schools. Its leading figures were the Sakya-trained Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo (1820–1892), the Kagyu author Jamgon Kongtrul (1813–1899) and the Nyingma treasure revealer Chokgyur Lingpa (1829–1870), joined by Patrul Rinpoche, Mipham and others. The movement arose after centuries of sectarian conflict and at a time when many smaller lineages were close to dying out.","Rime is not a school and did not seek to merge the traditions into one. Its principle is that each lineage is a valid and complete path whose particular methods should be kept intact, and that a practitioner should be rooted in one tradition while respecting and learning from the others. In practice this meant seeking out rare transmissions and publishing them. The results were vast compilations: Kongtrul’s Five Great Treasuries, including the Treasury of Instructions arranged by the eight practice lineages, and the Sakya-based Compendium of Sadhanas and Compendium of Tantras. There was also a turn back to Indian sources, seen in Khenpo Shenga’s commentaries on thirteen classic treatises.","Many teachings practised today in the Kagyu, Nyingma and Sakya schools owe their survival to these collections, and teachers trained in the Rime spirit, such as Jamyang Khyentse Chokyi Lodro, Dilgo Khyentse and Kalu Rinpoche, were prominent in transmitting Buddhism after 1959. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama, a Gelug monk, has taken teachings from masters of all schools and commends the approach. Scholars note that the label ‘movement’ is a modern one and that nonsectarian attitudes have earlier precedents in Tibet."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"Mid-19th century, Derge, Kham"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo; Jamgon Kongtrul; Chokgyur Lingpa"},{"label":"Head","value":"None; an approach, not an institution"},{"label":"Centres","value":"Dzongsar; Palpung; Shechen; Dzogchen"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Respect for and preservation of every lineage"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Five Great Treasuries; Compendium of Sadhanas; Compendium of Tantras"},{"label":"Schools involved","value":"Sakya, Kagyu and Nyingma; also Jonang, Bön and some Gelug teachers"},{"label":"Region","value":"Kham, eastern Tibet"}],"related":["masters/jamgon-kongtrul","masters/jamyang-khyentse-wangpo","masters/mipham-rinpoche","masters/patrul-rinpoche","texts/treasury-of-knowledge","masters/dilgo-khyentse","places/derge-parkhang","schools/shangpa-kagyu","places/palpung","history/rime-movement-emerges","texts/rinchen-terdzo"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Rimé movement — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rimé_movement"},{"title":"E. Gene Smith, Among Tibetan Texts: History and Literature of the Himalayan Plateau (Wisdom Publications, 2001)","url":""},{"title":"Alexander Gardner, The Life of Jamgon Kongtrul the Great (Snow Lion, 2019)","url":""},{"title":"Ringu Tulku, The Ri-me Philosophy of Jamgön Kongtrul the Great (Shambhala, 2006)","url":""}]},{"id":"chod-tradition","url":"https://forevertibet.com/schools/chod-tradition/","code":"FT·SCH·012","name":"Chod Tradition","aliases":["Chod","Chöd","Cho","Severance","Cutting Through","Gcod"],"tibetan":"གཅོད","wylie":"gcod","sanskrit":"","category":"Movement & Practice Lineage","era":"11th–12th century","summary":"Practice lineage founded by Machig Labdron, in which the meditator cuts through self-clinging by offering the body in visualisation, accompanied by drum and bell.","body":["Chod, ‘cutting’ or ‘severance’, is a system of meditation and ritual that took shape in Tibet in the late eleventh and twelfth centuries. Its founder was the Tibetan woman teacher Machig Labdron (1055–1149), who drew on the Perfection of Wisdom sutras and on instructions from the Indian adept Padampa Sangye, founder of the related Zhije or ‘pacification’ tradition. Chod never became a separate monastic school. It is a lineage of practice transmitted within all the schools, and tradition describes it as the one teaching that travelled from Tibet to India.","What is cut is clinging to a self, the root of suffering in Buddhist analysis. Machig taught that the real ‘demons’ are not external beings but whatever obstructs freedom: attachment to pleasant and unpleasant experience, pride in attainment, and above all self-grasping. In the core practice the meditator, after generating compassion, ejects consciousness from the body, which is then imagined as cut up, transformed into nectar and offered to buddhas, protectors, spirits and all beings to whom karmic debts are owed. The liturgy is sung to a hand drum, bell and thighbone trumpet. Traditionally it was performed alone at night in charnel grounds and other frightening places.","Lines of transmission are called ‘father’, ‘mother’ and ‘experiential’ Chod. Well-known forms include those of the Karma Kagyu, shaped by the third Karmapa; the Nyingma ‘Laughter of the Dakinis’ from the Longchen Nyingthig and the Dudjom treasures; a Gelug ‘Ganden ear-whispered’ lineage; and Bön Chod traditions with their own revealed texts. Chod practitioners, some of them itinerant, were called on to perform rites for the sick and the dead and to handle corpses in epidemics. The practice is widely taught today, including in adapted forms outside Tibetan communities."],"facts":[{"label":"Founded","value":"Late 11th–12th century"},{"label":"Founder","value":"Machig Labdron"},{"label":"Head","value":"None; transmitted within all schools"},{"label":"Associated site","value":"Zangri Khangmar, seat of Machig Labdron"},{"label":"Core teachings","value":"Cutting self-clinging; offering the body; Perfection of Wisdom"},{"label":"Key texts","value":"Kahtsom Chenmo (Great Bundle of Precepts); Machik's Complete Explanation"},{"label":"Ritual implements","value":"Chod drum; bell; thighbone trumpet"},{"label":"Related tradition","value":"Zhije (pacification) of Padampa Sangye"}],"related":["masters/machig-labdron","concepts/chod","symbols/damaru","deities/prajnaparamita-goddess","concepts/dakini","concepts/emptiness","concepts/compassion","concepts/phowa","deities/troma-nagmo","symbols/kangling","masters/thangtong-gyalpo","schools/bon","history/machig-labdron-and-chod","history/thangtong-gyalpo-iron-bridges","texts/blue-annals"],"artworks":[],"sources":[{"title":"Chöd — Wikipedia","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chöd"},{"title":"Sarah Harding (trans.), Machik's Complete Explanation: Clarifying the Meaning of Chöd (Snow Lion, 2003)","url":""},{"title":"Jérôme Edou, Machig Labdrön and the Foundations of Chöd (Snow Lion, 1996)","url":""}]}]}